| Platinum | Bremer Jewelry Peoria |
| Gold | Curious Baubles |
| Silver | Pumpkin Glass Gallery & Studio |
| Bronze | Rogers & Hollands |
| Top Pick | Carlson's Custom Jewelry |
| Top Pick | Jones Bros. Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Kevin Kelly Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Km Jewelry Design |
| Top Pick | Potter & Anderson Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Vena Fine Jewelry |