| Platinum | Two Sisters and A Warehouse |
| Gold | Helping Hands Peoria Heights |
| Silver | Urban Artifacts |
| Bronze | The Pickers Daughter |
| Top Pick | Church Mouse Thrift Shop |
| Top Pick | Goodwill |
| Top Pick | Habitat For Humanity Re-Store |
| Top Pick | Helping Hands - Chillicothe |
| Top Pick | Pink Blossom Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | The Hope Chest |