| Platinum | The Pickers Daughter |
| Gold | Relics |
| Silver | Maneki Permanent Jewelry & Gift Shop |
| Bronze | Gift Booktique At Peoria Book Rack |
| Top Pick | Buskirk's Gift Shop At The Silo |
| Top Pick | Cranberry Creek |
| Top Pick | Indie Gift House |
| Top Pick | Peoria Flag & Decorating Co |
| Top Pick | The Wink House |
| Top Pick | Two Sisters and A Warehouse |