| Platinum | Rubi's Brick Oven Pizza |
| Gold | Agatucci's Restaurant |
| Gold | Oliver's Pizza & Pub North |
| Silver | Sugar Wood-Fired Bistro |
| Bronze | Rosati's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Monical's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Nick-N-Willy's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Peoria Pizza and Works |
| Top Pick | Pizza Works |
| Top Pick | Weaver's |