| Platinum | Rizzi's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Avanti's Ristorante |
| Silver | Agatucci's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Paparazzi |
| Top Pick | Brienzo's Wood Fired Pizza |
| Top Pick | Chicago Grill |
| Top Pick | Connected |
| Top Pick | Joe's Original Italian & Martini Bar |
| Top Pick | Johnny's Italian Steakhouse |