| Platinum | Emack & Bolio's |
| Gold | Yeni's Palarte |
| Silver | Emo's Dairy Mart |
| Bronze | Theo's |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen Grill & Chill |
| Top Pick | Double D's Soft Serve |
| Top Pick | La Delicias |
| Top Pick | Sweet Cece's |
| Top Pick | Tall Bob's Ice Cream Roundup |
| Top Pick | Twistee Treat |